Industrial requirements for thermodynamics and transport properties

Eric Hendriks, Georgios M. Kontogeorgis, Ralf Dohrn, Jean Charles De Hemptinne, Ioannis Economou, Ljudmila Fele Ẑilnik, Velisa Vesovic

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

153 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This work reports the results of an investigation on industrial requirements for thermodynamic and transport properties carried out by the Working Party on Thermodynamic and Transport properties (http://www.wp-ttp.dk/) of the European Federation of Chemical Engineering, EFCE (http://www.efce.info/) . A carefully designed questionnaire was sent to a number of key technical people in companies in the oil and gas, chemicals, and pharmaceutical/ biotechnology sectors. Twenty-eight companies have provided answers which formed the basis for the analysis presented here. A number of previous reviews, specifically addressed to or written by industrial colleagues, are discussed initially. This provides the context of the survey and material with which the results of the survey can be compared. The results of the survey have been divided into the themes: data, models, systems, properties, education, and collaboration. The main results are as follows. There is (still) an acute need for accurate, reliable, and thermodynamically consistent experimental data. Quality is more important than quantity. Similarly, there is a great need for reliable predictive, rather than correlative, models covering a wide range of compositions, temperatures, and pressures and capable of predicting primary (phase equilibrium) and secondary (enthalpy, heat capacity, etc.) properties. It is clear that the ideal of a single model covering all requirements is not achievable, but there is a consensus that this ideal should still provide the direction for future development. The use of new methods, such as SAFT, is increasing, but they are not yet in position to replace traditional methods such as cubic equations of state (especially in oil and gas industry) and the UNIFAC group contribution approach. A common problem with novel methods is lack of standardization, reference data, and correct and transparent implementations, especially in commercially available simulation programs. The survey indicates a great variety of systems where further work is required. For instance, for electrolyte systems better models are needed, capable of describing all types of phase behavior and mixtures with other types of components. There is also a lack of data and methods for larger complex molecules. Compared with the previous reviews, complex mixtures containing carbon dioxide associated with a wide range of applications, such as capture, transport, and storage are becoming interesting to a number of survey participants. Despite the academic success of molecular simulation techniques, the survey does not indicate great interest in it or its future development. Algorithms appear to be a neglected area, but improvements are still needed especially for multiphase reactive systems (simultaneous chemical and physical equilibrium). Education in thermodynamics is perceived as key, for the future application of thermodynamics in the industry. A number of suggestions for improvement were made at all three levels (undergraduate, postgraduate, and professional development) indicating that the education is correctly perceived as an ongoing process.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)11131-11141
Number of pages11
JournalIndustrial and Engineering Chemistry Research
Volume49
Issue number22
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 17 Nov 2010
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Transport properties
Thermodynamic properties
Education
Oils
Thermodynamics
Industry
Gas industry
Chemical engineering
Phase behavior
Biotechnology
Complex Mixtures
Equations of state
Carbon Dioxide
Phase equilibria
Drug products
Standardization
Electrolytes
Specific heat
Data structures
Enthalpy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Chemical Engineering(all)
  • Chemistry(all)
  • Industrial and Manufacturing Engineering

Cite this

Hendriks, E., Kontogeorgis, G. M., Dohrn, R., De Hemptinne, J. C., Economou, I., Ẑilnik, L. F., & Vesovic, V. (2010). Industrial requirements for thermodynamics and transport properties. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 49(22), 11131-11141. https://doi.org/10.1021/ie101231b

Industrial requirements for thermodynamics and transport properties. / Hendriks, Eric; Kontogeorgis, Georgios M.; Dohrn, Ralf; De Hemptinne, Jean Charles; Economou, Ioannis; Ẑilnik, Ljudmila Fele; Vesovic, Velisa.

In: Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, Vol. 49, No. 22, 17.11.2010, p. 11131-11141.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hendriks, E, Kontogeorgis, GM, Dohrn, R, De Hemptinne, JC, Economou, I, Ẑilnik, LF & Vesovic, V 2010, 'Industrial requirements for thermodynamics and transport properties', Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, vol. 49, no. 22, pp. 11131-11141. https://doi.org/10.1021/ie101231b
Hendriks E, Kontogeorgis GM, Dohrn R, De Hemptinne JC, Economou I, Ẑilnik LF et al. Industrial requirements for thermodynamics and transport properties. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research. 2010 Nov 17;49(22):11131-11141. https://doi.org/10.1021/ie101231b
Hendriks, Eric ; Kontogeorgis, Georgios M. ; Dohrn, Ralf ; De Hemptinne, Jean Charles ; Economou, Ioannis ; Ẑilnik, Ljudmila Fele ; Vesovic, Velisa. / Industrial requirements for thermodynamics and transport properties. In: Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research. 2010 ; Vol. 49, No. 22. pp. 11131-11141.
@article{056084a5c07a4306b4cc8e27cc461a6d,
title = "Industrial requirements for thermodynamics and transport properties",
abstract = "This work reports the results of an investigation on industrial requirements for thermodynamic and transport properties carried out by the Working Party on Thermodynamic and Transport properties (http://www.wp-ttp.dk/) of the European Federation of Chemical Engineering, EFCE (http://www.efce.info/) . A carefully designed questionnaire was sent to a number of key technical people in companies in the oil and gas, chemicals, and pharmaceutical/ biotechnology sectors. Twenty-eight companies have provided answers which formed the basis for the analysis presented here. A number of previous reviews, specifically addressed to or written by industrial colleagues, are discussed initially. This provides the context of the survey and material with which the results of the survey can be compared. The results of the survey have been divided into the themes: data, models, systems, properties, education, and collaboration. The main results are as follows. There is (still) an acute need for accurate, reliable, and thermodynamically consistent experimental data. Quality is more important than quantity. Similarly, there is a great need for reliable predictive, rather than correlative, models covering a wide range of compositions, temperatures, and pressures and capable of predicting primary (phase equilibrium) and secondary (enthalpy, heat capacity, etc.) properties. It is clear that the ideal of a single model covering all requirements is not achievable, but there is a consensus that this ideal should still provide the direction for future development. The use of new methods, such as SAFT, is increasing, but they are not yet in position to replace traditional methods such as cubic equations of state (especially in oil and gas industry) and the UNIFAC group contribution approach. A common problem with novel methods is lack of standardization, reference data, and correct and transparent implementations, especially in commercially available simulation programs. The survey indicates a great variety of systems where further work is required. For instance, for electrolyte systems better models are needed, capable of describing all types of phase behavior and mixtures with other types of components. There is also a lack of data and methods for larger complex molecules. Compared with the previous reviews, complex mixtures containing carbon dioxide associated with a wide range of applications, such as capture, transport, and storage are becoming interesting to a number of survey participants. Despite the academic success of molecular simulation techniques, the survey does not indicate great interest in it or its future development. Algorithms appear to be a neglected area, but improvements are still needed especially for multiphase reactive systems (simultaneous chemical and physical equilibrium). Education in thermodynamics is perceived as key, for the future application of thermodynamics in the industry. A number of suggestions for improvement were made at all three levels (undergraduate, postgraduate, and professional development) indicating that the education is correctly perceived as an ongoing process.",
author = "Eric Hendriks and Kontogeorgis, {Georgios M.} and Ralf Dohrn and {De Hemptinne}, {Jean Charles} and Ioannis Economou and Ẑilnik, {Ljudmila Fele} and Velisa Vesovic",
year = "2010",
month = "11",
day = "17",
doi = "10.1021/ie101231b",
language = "English",
volume = "49",
pages = "11131--11141",
journal = "Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research",
issn = "0888-5885",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
number = "22",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Industrial requirements for thermodynamics and transport properties

AU - Hendriks, Eric

AU - Kontogeorgis, Georgios M.

AU - Dohrn, Ralf

AU - De Hemptinne, Jean Charles

AU - Economou, Ioannis

AU - Ẑilnik, Ljudmila Fele

AU - Vesovic, Velisa

PY - 2010/11/17

Y1 - 2010/11/17

N2 - This work reports the results of an investigation on industrial requirements for thermodynamic and transport properties carried out by the Working Party on Thermodynamic and Transport properties (http://www.wp-ttp.dk/) of the European Federation of Chemical Engineering, EFCE (http://www.efce.info/) . A carefully designed questionnaire was sent to a number of key technical people in companies in the oil and gas, chemicals, and pharmaceutical/ biotechnology sectors. Twenty-eight companies have provided answers which formed the basis for the analysis presented here. A number of previous reviews, specifically addressed to or written by industrial colleagues, are discussed initially. This provides the context of the survey and material with which the results of the survey can be compared. The results of the survey have been divided into the themes: data, models, systems, properties, education, and collaboration. The main results are as follows. There is (still) an acute need for accurate, reliable, and thermodynamically consistent experimental data. Quality is more important than quantity. Similarly, there is a great need for reliable predictive, rather than correlative, models covering a wide range of compositions, temperatures, and pressures and capable of predicting primary (phase equilibrium) and secondary (enthalpy, heat capacity, etc.) properties. It is clear that the ideal of a single model covering all requirements is not achievable, but there is a consensus that this ideal should still provide the direction for future development. The use of new methods, such as SAFT, is increasing, but they are not yet in position to replace traditional methods such as cubic equations of state (especially in oil and gas industry) and the UNIFAC group contribution approach. A common problem with novel methods is lack of standardization, reference data, and correct and transparent implementations, especially in commercially available simulation programs. The survey indicates a great variety of systems where further work is required. For instance, for electrolyte systems better models are needed, capable of describing all types of phase behavior and mixtures with other types of components. There is also a lack of data and methods for larger complex molecules. Compared with the previous reviews, complex mixtures containing carbon dioxide associated with a wide range of applications, such as capture, transport, and storage are becoming interesting to a number of survey participants. Despite the academic success of molecular simulation techniques, the survey does not indicate great interest in it or its future development. Algorithms appear to be a neglected area, but improvements are still needed especially for multiphase reactive systems (simultaneous chemical and physical equilibrium). Education in thermodynamics is perceived as key, for the future application of thermodynamics in the industry. A number of suggestions for improvement were made at all three levels (undergraduate, postgraduate, and professional development) indicating that the education is correctly perceived as an ongoing process.

AB - This work reports the results of an investigation on industrial requirements for thermodynamic and transport properties carried out by the Working Party on Thermodynamic and Transport properties (http://www.wp-ttp.dk/) of the European Federation of Chemical Engineering, EFCE (http://www.efce.info/) . A carefully designed questionnaire was sent to a number of key technical people in companies in the oil and gas, chemicals, and pharmaceutical/ biotechnology sectors. Twenty-eight companies have provided answers which formed the basis for the analysis presented here. A number of previous reviews, specifically addressed to or written by industrial colleagues, are discussed initially. This provides the context of the survey and material with which the results of the survey can be compared. The results of the survey have been divided into the themes: data, models, systems, properties, education, and collaboration. The main results are as follows. There is (still) an acute need for accurate, reliable, and thermodynamically consistent experimental data. Quality is more important than quantity. Similarly, there is a great need for reliable predictive, rather than correlative, models covering a wide range of compositions, temperatures, and pressures and capable of predicting primary (phase equilibrium) and secondary (enthalpy, heat capacity, etc.) properties. It is clear that the ideal of a single model covering all requirements is not achievable, but there is a consensus that this ideal should still provide the direction for future development. The use of new methods, such as SAFT, is increasing, but they are not yet in position to replace traditional methods such as cubic equations of state (especially in oil and gas industry) and the UNIFAC group contribution approach. A common problem with novel methods is lack of standardization, reference data, and correct and transparent implementations, especially in commercially available simulation programs. The survey indicates a great variety of systems where further work is required. For instance, for electrolyte systems better models are needed, capable of describing all types of phase behavior and mixtures with other types of components. There is also a lack of data and methods for larger complex molecules. Compared with the previous reviews, complex mixtures containing carbon dioxide associated with a wide range of applications, such as capture, transport, and storage are becoming interesting to a number of survey participants. Despite the academic success of molecular simulation techniques, the survey does not indicate great interest in it or its future development. Algorithms appear to be a neglected area, but improvements are still needed especially for multiphase reactive systems (simultaneous chemical and physical equilibrium). Education in thermodynamics is perceived as key, for the future application of thermodynamics in the industry. A number of suggestions for improvement were made at all three levels (undergraduate, postgraduate, and professional development) indicating that the education is correctly perceived as an ongoing process.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=78449291910&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=78449291910&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1021/ie101231b

DO - 10.1021/ie101231b

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:78449291910

VL - 49

SP - 11131

EP - 11141

JO - Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research

JF - Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research

SN - 0888-5885

IS - 22

ER -