Exergy and thermoeconomic evaluation of MSF process using a new visual package

A. S. Nafey, H. E S Fath, Abdelnasser Aboukhlewa

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

44 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper presents a methodology of exergy and thermoeconomic analysis for performance of the Multi-Stage Flash (MSF) process using the developed package. This methodology gets insight on details not available by the first law analysis. The main target of these analyses is to improve the MSF process as well as to determine the unit product cost of the distilled water. Using the developed VDS package, the energy analysis of the considered MSF plant in the rating mode (performance), the gain ratio (GR) is calculated as 7.91. The exergy input, ĖF, to the MSF plant is calculated as 10.7 MW which represents the exergy of the heating steam, exergy associated to the sea water feed, and electrical pumping power minus the exergy of the brine heater condensate. Only 0.2 MW of an elevated exergy in the distilled stream is produced. The exergy associated with blow down and rejection of cooling streams is 4.04 MW which nominated as an exergy loss. The remainder part of ĖD = 6.46 MW is destroyed internally in the plant components as a result the exergetic efficiency of the considered MSF plant, ηII 1.87%. The unit product cost of the MSF desalination plant is calculated as 2.63 $/m3 by two different ways. The first one by calculating the capital and running costs which invested at the boundary of the MSF plant (input streams); the second way is based on mathematical model (thermoeconomics) by which the outlet streams cost is calculated and charged their value to the desalted water. Thermoeconomic analysis shows that the overall cost of the desalination plant will be obtained if the exergy destruction rate of the desuperheater, the distiller train is reduced. The monetary cost of the streams indicated that any modifications in the first stages will cause more effect other than the last stages. Different partial load conditions for the real data of Eoun Mousa MSF plant are depicted and recorded by Data Control System (DCS). These data are fed to the developed VDS software to investigate the performance of the MSF plant. The distillate product varies from 104 (50%) m3/h to 208 (100%) m3/h as well as the top brine temperature varies from 86 to 110°C. The heating steam consumption varies from 12 to 26 m3/h. Thermoeconomic analysis of MSF plant under different partial load conditions showed that the unit product cost increases to 21% when the load decreases to 50% of its design value.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)224-240
Number of pages17
JournalDesalination
Volume201
Issue number1-3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 30 Nov 2006
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

exergy
Exergy
Costs
cost
Steam
Desalination
brine
Water
heating
evaluation
Heating
methodology
condensate
train
control system
pumping
analysis
Mathematical models
Cooling
seawater

Keywords

  • design and simulation MSF plant
  • Exergy
  • Thermoeconomics
  • Visual package

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Filtration and Separation

Cite this

Exergy and thermoeconomic evaluation of MSF process using a new visual package. / Nafey, A. S.; Fath, H. E S; Aboukhlewa, Abdelnasser.

In: Desalination, Vol. 201, No. 1-3, 30.11.2006, p. 224-240.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{3c09fed9f32643d7952213568966ed7f,
title = "Exergy and thermoeconomic evaluation of MSF process using a new visual package",
abstract = "This paper presents a methodology of exergy and thermoeconomic analysis for performance of the Multi-Stage Flash (MSF) process using the developed package. This methodology gets insight on details not available by the first law analysis. The main target of these analyses is to improve the MSF process as well as to determine the unit product cost of the distilled water. Using the developed VDS package, the energy analysis of the considered MSF plant in the rating mode (performance), the gain ratio (GR) is calculated as 7.91. The exergy input, ĖF, to the MSF plant is calculated as 10.7 MW which represents the exergy of the heating steam, exergy associated to the sea water feed, and electrical pumping power minus the exergy of the brine heater condensate. Only 0.2 MW of an elevated exergy in the distilled stream is produced. The exergy associated with blow down and rejection of cooling streams is 4.04 MW which nominated as an exergy loss. The remainder part of ĖD = 6.46 MW is destroyed internally in the plant components as a result the exergetic efficiency of the considered MSF plant, ηII 1.87{\%}. The unit product cost of the MSF desalination plant is calculated as 2.63 $/m3 by two different ways. The first one by calculating the capital and running costs which invested at the boundary of the MSF plant (input streams); the second way is based on mathematical model (thermoeconomics) by which the outlet streams cost is calculated and charged their value to the desalted water. Thermoeconomic analysis shows that the overall cost of the desalination plant will be obtained if the exergy destruction rate of the desuperheater, the distiller train is reduced. The monetary cost of the streams indicated that any modifications in the first stages will cause more effect other than the last stages. Different partial load conditions for the real data of Eoun Mousa MSF plant are depicted and recorded by Data Control System (DCS). These data are fed to the developed VDS software to investigate the performance of the MSF plant. The distillate product varies from 104 (50{\%}) m3/h to 208 (100{\%}) m3/h as well as the top brine temperature varies from 86 to 110°C. The heating steam consumption varies from 12 to 26 m3/h. Thermoeconomic analysis of MSF plant under different partial load conditions showed that the unit product cost increases to 21{\%} when the load decreases to 50{\%} of its design value.",
keywords = "design and simulation MSF plant, Exergy, Thermoeconomics, Visual package",
author = "Nafey, {A. S.} and Fath, {H. E S} and Abdelnasser Aboukhlewa",
year = "2006",
month = "11",
day = "30",
doi = "10.1016/j.desal.2005.09.043",
language = "English",
volume = "201",
pages = "224--240",
journal = "Desalination",
issn = "0011-9164",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1-3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Exergy and thermoeconomic evaluation of MSF process using a new visual package

AU - Nafey, A. S.

AU - Fath, H. E S

AU - Aboukhlewa, Abdelnasser

PY - 2006/11/30

Y1 - 2006/11/30

N2 - This paper presents a methodology of exergy and thermoeconomic analysis for performance of the Multi-Stage Flash (MSF) process using the developed package. This methodology gets insight on details not available by the first law analysis. The main target of these analyses is to improve the MSF process as well as to determine the unit product cost of the distilled water. Using the developed VDS package, the energy analysis of the considered MSF plant in the rating mode (performance), the gain ratio (GR) is calculated as 7.91. The exergy input, ĖF, to the MSF plant is calculated as 10.7 MW which represents the exergy of the heating steam, exergy associated to the sea water feed, and electrical pumping power minus the exergy of the brine heater condensate. Only 0.2 MW of an elevated exergy in the distilled stream is produced. The exergy associated with blow down and rejection of cooling streams is 4.04 MW which nominated as an exergy loss. The remainder part of ĖD = 6.46 MW is destroyed internally in the plant components as a result the exergetic efficiency of the considered MSF plant, ηII 1.87%. The unit product cost of the MSF desalination plant is calculated as 2.63 $/m3 by two different ways. The first one by calculating the capital and running costs which invested at the boundary of the MSF plant (input streams); the second way is based on mathematical model (thermoeconomics) by which the outlet streams cost is calculated and charged their value to the desalted water. Thermoeconomic analysis shows that the overall cost of the desalination plant will be obtained if the exergy destruction rate of the desuperheater, the distiller train is reduced. The monetary cost of the streams indicated that any modifications in the first stages will cause more effect other than the last stages. Different partial load conditions for the real data of Eoun Mousa MSF plant are depicted and recorded by Data Control System (DCS). These data are fed to the developed VDS software to investigate the performance of the MSF plant. The distillate product varies from 104 (50%) m3/h to 208 (100%) m3/h as well as the top brine temperature varies from 86 to 110°C. The heating steam consumption varies from 12 to 26 m3/h. Thermoeconomic analysis of MSF plant under different partial load conditions showed that the unit product cost increases to 21% when the load decreases to 50% of its design value.

AB - This paper presents a methodology of exergy and thermoeconomic analysis for performance of the Multi-Stage Flash (MSF) process using the developed package. This methodology gets insight on details not available by the first law analysis. The main target of these analyses is to improve the MSF process as well as to determine the unit product cost of the distilled water. Using the developed VDS package, the energy analysis of the considered MSF plant in the rating mode (performance), the gain ratio (GR) is calculated as 7.91. The exergy input, ĖF, to the MSF plant is calculated as 10.7 MW which represents the exergy of the heating steam, exergy associated to the sea water feed, and electrical pumping power minus the exergy of the brine heater condensate. Only 0.2 MW of an elevated exergy in the distilled stream is produced. The exergy associated with blow down and rejection of cooling streams is 4.04 MW which nominated as an exergy loss. The remainder part of ĖD = 6.46 MW is destroyed internally in the plant components as a result the exergetic efficiency of the considered MSF plant, ηII 1.87%. The unit product cost of the MSF desalination plant is calculated as 2.63 $/m3 by two different ways. The first one by calculating the capital and running costs which invested at the boundary of the MSF plant (input streams); the second way is based on mathematical model (thermoeconomics) by which the outlet streams cost is calculated and charged their value to the desalted water. Thermoeconomic analysis shows that the overall cost of the desalination plant will be obtained if the exergy destruction rate of the desuperheater, the distiller train is reduced. The monetary cost of the streams indicated that any modifications in the first stages will cause more effect other than the last stages. Different partial load conditions for the real data of Eoun Mousa MSF plant are depicted and recorded by Data Control System (DCS). These data are fed to the developed VDS software to investigate the performance of the MSF plant. The distillate product varies from 104 (50%) m3/h to 208 (100%) m3/h as well as the top brine temperature varies from 86 to 110°C. The heating steam consumption varies from 12 to 26 m3/h. Thermoeconomic analysis of MSF plant under different partial load conditions showed that the unit product cost increases to 21% when the load decreases to 50% of its design value.

KW - design and simulation MSF plant

KW - Exergy

KW - Thermoeconomics

KW - Visual package

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33751193266&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33751193266&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.desal.2005.09.043

DO - 10.1016/j.desal.2005.09.043

M3 - Article

VL - 201

SP - 224

EP - 240

JO - Desalination

JF - Desalination

SN - 0011-9164

IS - 1-3

ER -