Evaluation of FO-RO and PRO-RO designs for power generation and seawater desalination using impaired water feeds

Ali Altaee, Adel Sharif, Guillermo Zaragoza, Ahmad Fauzi Ismail

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    22 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    PRO and FO coupling with an RO membrane process is proposed to reduce the cost of seawater desalination and the potential for power generation. Three conceptual design configurations, PRO-RO, FO-RO and RO-PRO were evaluated here using standard seawater concentration and impaired water as the draw and the feed solutions respectively. The PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs were evaluated for power generation and seawater desalination while the FO-RO design was proposed for seawater desalination only. The impact of the draw and feed solutions' flow rate and the impaired water TDS on the performance of each design was estimated using pre-developed software. The simulation results showed that the performance of all designs was more sensitive to the increase in the flow rate of draw solution than to the flow rate of feed solution. Furthermore, all designs showed a decrease in membrane flux and recovery rate with increasing the TDS of feed water from 0.2. g/L to 10. g/L as a result of decreasing the net driving force across the membrane and the concentration polarization phenomenon. The FO-RO design produced the lowest RO permeate concentration followed by the PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively. In terms of power generation, the RO-PRO design was more efficient than the PRO-RO design. The FO-RO design exhibited the lowest desalination power consumption followed by the PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively. At 10. g/L feed concentration, the net power consumption in the FO-RO was 9.4% less than that in the PRO-RO which was in turn 5.3% less than that in the RO-PRO design. The estimated cost of the FO/PRO module in the PRO-RO design was 2.2 and 4.3 times higher than that in the FO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively.

    Original languageEnglish
    JournalDesalination
    Volume368
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 18 May 2014

    Fingerprint

    Desalination
    Seawater
    power generation
    desalination
    Power generation
    seawater
    Water
    water
    Flow rate
    evaluation
    Membranes
    membrane
    Electric power utilization
    Conceptual design
    cost
    Costs

    Keywords

    • Forward osmosis
    • Osmotic energy
    • Pressure retarded osmosis
    • Reverse osmosis
    • Seawater desalination

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Chemical Engineering(all)
    • Mechanical Engineering
    • Chemistry(all)
    • Materials Science(all)
    • Water Science and Technology

    Cite this

    Evaluation of FO-RO and PRO-RO designs for power generation and seawater desalination using impaired water feeds. / Altaee, Ali; Sharif, Adel; Zaragoza, Guillermo; Ismail, Ahmad Fauzi.

    In: Desalination, Vol. 368, 18.05.2014.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    @article{fd322384c21b454683a9af7842c49a21,
    title = "Evaluation of FO-RO and PRO-RO designs for power generation and seawater desalination using impaired water feeds",
    abstract = "PRO and FO coupling with an RO membrane process is proposed to reduce the cost of seawater desalination and the potential for power generation. Three conceptual design configurations, PRO-RO, FO-RO and RO-PRO were evaluated here using standard seawater concentration and impaired water as the draw and the feed solutions respectively. The PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs were evaluated for power generation and seawater desalination while the FO-RO design was proposed for seawater desalination only. The impact of the draw and feed solutions' flow rate and the impaired water TDS on the performance of each design was estimated using pre-developed software. The simulation results showed that the performance of all designs was more sensitive to the increase in the flow rate of draw solution than to the flow rate of feed solution. Furthermore, all designs showed a decrease in membrane flux and recovery rate with increasing the TDS of feed water from 0.2. g/L to 10. g/L as a result of decreasing the net driving force across the membrane and the concentration polarization phenomenon. The FO-RO design produced the lowest RO permeate concentration followed by the PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively. In terms of power generation, the RO-PRO design was more efficient than the PRO-RO design. The FO-RO design exhibited the lowest desalination power consumption followed by the PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively. At 10. g/L feed concentration, the net power consumption in the FO-RO was 9.4{\%} less than that in the PRO-RO which was in turn 5.3{\%} less than that in the RO-PRO design. The estimated cost of the FO/PRO module in the PRO-RO design was 2.2 and 4.3 times higher than that in the FO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively.",
    keywords = "Forward osmosis, Osmotic energy, Pressure retarded osmosis, Reverse osmosis, Seawater desalination",
    author = "Ali Altaee and Adel Sharif and Guillermo Zaragoza and Ismail, {Ahmad Fauzi}",
    year = "2014",
    month = "5",
    day = "18",
    doi = "10.1016/j.desal.2014.06.022",
    language = "English",
    volume = "368",
    journal = "Desalination",
    issn = "0011-9164",
    publisher = "Elsevier",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Evaluation of FO-RO and PRO-RO designs for power generation and seawater desalination using impaired water feeds

    AU - Altaee, Ali

    AU - Sharif, Adel

    AU - Zaragoza, Guillermo

    AU - Ismail, Ahmad Fauzi

    PY - 2014/5/18

    Y1 - 2014/5/18

    N2 - PRO and FO coupling with an RO membrane process is proposed to reduce the cost of seawater desalination and the potential for power generation. Three conceptual design configurations, PRO-RO, FO-RO and RO-PRO were evaluated here using standard seawater concentration and impaired water as the draw and the feed solutions respectively. The PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs were evaluated for power generation and seawater desalination while the FO-RO design was proposed for seawater desalination only. The impact of the draw and feed solutions' flow rate and the impaired water TDS on the performance of each design was estimated using pre-developed software. The simulation results showed that the performance of all designs was more sensitive to the increase in the flow rate of draw solution than to the flow rate of feed solution. Furthermore, all designs showed a decrease in membrane flux and recovery rate with increasing the TDS of feed water from 0.2. g/L to 10. g/L as a result of decreasing the net driving force across the membrane and the concentration polarization phenomenon. The FO-RO design produced the lowest RO permeate concentration followed by the PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively. In terms of power generation, the RO-PRO design was more efficient than the PRO-RO design. The FO-RO design exhibited the lowest desalination power consumption followed by the PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively. At 10. g/L feed concentration, the net power consumption in the FO-RO was 9.4% less than that in the PRO-RO which was in turn 5.3% less than that in the RO-PRO design. The estimated cost of the FO/PRO module in the PRO-RO design was 2.2 and 4.3 times higher than that in the FO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively.

    AB - PRO and FO coupling with an RO membrane process is proposed to reduce the cost of seawater desalination and the potential for power generation. Three conceptual design configurations, PRO-RO, FO-RO and RO-PRO were evaluated here using standard seawater concentration and impaired water as the draw and the feed solutions respectively. The PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs were evaluated for power generation and seawater desalination while the FO-RO design was proposed for seawater desalination only. The impact of the draw and feed solutions' flow rate and the impaired water TDS on the performance of each design was estimated using pre-developed software. The simulation results showed that the performance of all designs was more sensitive to the increase in the flow rate of draw solution than to the flow rate of feed solution. Furthermore, all designs showed a decrease in membrane flux and recovery rate with increasing the TDS of feed water from 0.2. g/L to 10. g/L as a result of decreasing the net driving force across the membrane and the concentration polarization phenomenon. The FO-RO design produced the lowest RO permeate concentration followed by the PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively. In terms of power generation, the RO-PRO design was more efficient than the PRO-RO design. The FO-RO design exhibited the lowest desalination power consumption followed by the PRO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively. At 10. g/L feed concentration, the net power consumption in the FO-RO was 9.4% less than that in the PRO-RO which was in turn 5.3% less than that in the RO-PRO design. The estimated cost of the FO/PRO module in the PRO-RO design was 2.2 and 4.3 times higher than that in the FO-RO and RO-PRO designs respectively.

    KW - Forward osmosis

    KW - Osmotic energy

    KW - Pressure retarded osmosis

    KW - Reverse osmosis

    KW - Seawater desalination

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84939886585&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84939886585&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.desal.2014.06.022

    DO - 10.1016/j.desal.2014.06.022

    M3 - Article

    VL - 368

    JO - Desalination

    JF - Desalination

    SN - 0011-9164

    ER -