Assessment and validation of evaporation models for cryogenic liquids

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The unanticipated release of cryogenic liquid is a serious safety risk since the vaporization of the cryogenic fuels may result in flammable vapor cloud which can lead to an explosion and/or fire. A significant amount of work has been carried out in the past to study the boiling phenomenon of cryogenic liquids. However, the evaporation of cryogenic liquid has not been thoroughly investigated. In reality, both of these phenomena are computationally equally important since during source term modeling, these two modes of vaporization are usually interchangeable. Incorrect source term prediction in any of these two regimes will result in poor estimation of consequences and hence will undermine the safety protocols. The interest to study evaporation mode of vaporization for cryogenic liquid stems from the fact that the boiling point of cryogens is below −150 °C and evaporation of cryogens will further decrease the temperature of the liquid, as observed through various evaporation models. However, these evaporation models have not been validated against the cryogenic liquid data. In order to fill this gap, the present study has three primary goals in context of cryogenic liquids: (i) understand and compare the existing evaporation models; (ii) evaluate the possibility of shift between boiling and evaporation regime; and (iii) validate the existing evaporation models. Six evaporation models were selected for this study through a comprehensive literature review. The behavior of the selected evaporation models was studied through a comprehensive parameter sensitivity analysis, including pool temperature, wind speed, ambient temperature, and pool size. Also, a medium scale experiment was performed, involving the spill of liquid nitrogen over polystyrene substrate, to observe the possibility of shift in the vaporization regime, and to validate the selected evaporation models. Although the results of the sensitivity analysis reflect on the possibility of evaporation of cryogenic liquids for some models, the experimental results confirm a complete absence of evaporation regime. Hence, based on the experimental results and sensitivity analysis, it was questioned through this work that the use of evaporation models in source term modeling may not be suitable for cryogenic liquids. However, more experiments should be carried out in future, on a larger scale, before coming to a general conclusion.

LanguageEnglish
Pages50-61
Number of pages12
JournalProcess Safety and Environmental Protection
Volume121
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2019

Fingerprint

Cryogenic liquids
Evaporation
evaporation
liquid
vaporization
Vaporization
Sensitivity analysis
sensitivity analysis
Boiling liquids
safety
temperature
Boiling point
Polystyrenes
Hazardous materials spills
Liquid nitrogen
literature review

Keywords

  • Cryogenic liquid
  • Evaporation
  • Liquid nitrogen
  • Source term modeling
  • Vaporization

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Environmental Engineering
  • Environmental Chemistry
  • Chemical Engineering(all)
  • Safety, Risk, Reliability and Quality

Cite this

Assessment and validation of evaporation models for cryogenic liquids. / Nawaz, Waqas; Olewski, Tomasz; Vechot, Luc.

In: Process Safety and Environmental Protection, Vol. 121, 01.01.2019, p. 50-61.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{7f1e66be6af0438b82adf0c3199d1e7b,
title = "Assessment and validation of evaporation models for cryogenic liquids",
abstract = "The unanticipated release of cryogenic liquid is a serious safety risk since the vaporization of the cryogenic fuels may result in flammable vapor cloud which can lead to an explosion and/or fire. A significant amount of work has been carried out in the past to study the boiling phenomenon of cryogenic liquids. However, the evaporation of cryogenic liquid has not been thoroughly investigated. In reality, both of these phenomena are computationally equally important since during source term modeling, these two modes of vaporization are usually interchangeable. Incorrect source term prediction in any of these two regimes will result in poor estimation of consequences and hence will undermine the safety protocols. The interest to study evaporation mode of vaporization for cryogenic liquid stems from the fact that the boiling point of cryogens is below −150 °C and evaporation of cryogens will further decrease the temperature of the liquid, as observed through various evaporation models. However, these evaporation models have not been validated against the cryogenic liquid data. In order to fill this gap, the present study has three primary goals in context of cryogenic liquids: (i) understand and compare the existing evaporation models; (ii) evaluate the possibility of shift between boiling and evaporation regime; and (iii) validate the existing evaporation models. Six evaporation models were selected for this study through a comprehensive literature review. The behavior of the selected evaporation models was studied through a comprehensive parameter sensitivity analysis, including pool temperature, wind speed, ambient temperature, and pool size. Also, a medium scale experiment was performed, involving the spill of liquid nitrogen over polystyrene substrate, to observe the possibility of shift in the vaporization regime, and to validate the selected evaporation models. Although the results of the sensitivity analysis reflect on the possibility of evaporation of cryogenic liquids for some models, the experimental results confirm a complete absence of evaporation regime. Hence, based on the experimental results and sensitivity analysis, it was questioned through this work that the use of evaporation models in source term modeling may not be suitable for cryogenic liquids. However, more experiments should be carried out in future, on a larger scale, before coming to a general conclusion.",
keywords = "Cryogenic liquid, Evaporation, Liquid nitrogen, Source term modeling, Vaporization",
author = "Waqas Nawaz and Tomasz Olewski and Luc Vechot",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.psep.2018.08.013",
language = "English",
volume = "121",
pages = "50--61",
journal = "Process Safety and Environmental Protection",
issn = "0957-5820",
publisher = "Institution of Chemical Engineers",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Assessment and validation of evaporation models for cryogenic liquids

AU - Nawaz, Waqas

AU - Olewski, Tomasz

AU - Vechot, Luc

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - The unanticipated release of cryogenic liquid is a serious safety risk since the vaporization of the cryogenic fuels may result in flammable vapor cloud which can lead to an explosion and/or fire. A significant amount of work has been carried out in the past to study the boiling phenomenon of cryogenic liquids. However, the evaporation of cryogenic liquid has not been thoroughly investigated. In reality, both of these phenomena are computationally equally important since during source term modeling, these two modes of vaporization are usually interchangeable. Incorrect source term prediction in any of these two regimes will result in poor estimation of consequences and hence will undermine the safety protocols. The interest to study evaporation mode of vaporization for cryogenic liquid stems from the fact that the boiling point of cryogens is below −150 °C and evaporation of cryogens will further decrease the temperature of the liquid, as observed through various evaporation models. However, these evaporation models have not been validated against the cryogenic liquid data. In order to fill this gap, the present study has three primary goals in context of cryogenic liquids: (i) understand and compare the existing evaporation models; (ii) evaluate the possibility of shift between boiling and evaporation regime; and (iii) validate the existing evaporation models. Six evaporation models were selected for this study through a comprehensive literature review. The behavior of the selected evaporation models was studied through a comprehensive parameter sensitivity analysis, including pool temperature, wind speed, ambient temperature, and pool size. Also, a medium scale experiment was performed, involving the spill of liquid nitrogen over polystyrene substrate, to observe the possibility of shift in the vaporization regime, and to validate the selected evaporation models. Although the results of the sensitivity analysis reflect on the possibility of evaporation of cryogenic liquids for some models, the experimental results confirm a complete absence of evaporation regime. Hence, based on the experimental results and sensitivity analysis, it was questioned through this work that the use of evaporation models in source term modeling may not be suitable for cryogenic liquids. However, more experiments should be carried out in future, on a larger scale, before coming to a general conclusion.

AB - The unanticipated release of cryogenic liquid is a serious safety risk since the vaporization of the cryogenic fuels may result in flammable vapor cloud which can lead to an explosion and/or fire. A significant amount of work has been carried out in the past to study the boiling phenomenon of cryogenic liquids. However, the evaporation of cryogenic liquid has not been thoroughly investigated. In reality, both of these phenomena are computationally equally important since during source term modeling, these two modes of vaporization are usually interchangeable. Incorrect source term prediction in any of these two regimes will result in poor estimation of consequences and hence will undermine the safety protocols. The interest to study evaporation mode of vaporization for cryogenic liquid stems from the fact that the boiling point of cryogens is below −150 °C and evaporation of cryogens will further decrease the temperature of the liquid, as observed through various evaporation models. However, these evaporation models have not been validated against the cryogenic liquid data. In order to fill this gap, the present study has three primary goals in context of cryogenic liquids: (i) understand and compare the existing evaporation models; (ii) evaluate the possibility of shift between boiling and evaporation regime; and (iii) validate the existing evaporation models. Six evaporation models were selected for this study through a comprehensive literature review. The behavior of the selected evaporation models was studied through a comprehensive parameter sensitivity analysis, including pool temperature, wind speed, ambient temperature, and pool size. Also, a medium scale experiment was performed, involving the spill of liquid nitrogen over polystyrene substrate, to observe the possibility of shift in the vaporization regime, and to validate the selected evaporation models. Although the results of the sensitivity analysis reflect on the possibility of evaporation of cryogenic liquids for some models, the experimental results confirm a complete absence of evaporation regime. Hence, based on the experimental results and sensitivity analysis, it was questioned through this work that the use of evaporation models in source term modeling may not be suitable for cryogenic liquids. However, more experiments should be carried out in future, on a larger scale, before coming to a general conclusion.

KW - Cryogenic liquid

KW - Evaporation

KW - Liquid nitrogen

KW - Source term modeling

KW - Vaporization

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85055287013&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85055287013&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.psep.2018.08.013

DO - 10.1016/j.psep.2018.08.013

M3 - Article

VL - 121

SP - 50

EP - 61

JO - Process Safety and Environmental Protection

T2 - Process Safety and Environmental Protection

JF - Process Safety and Environmental Protection

SN - 0957-5820

ER -