Apparent anti-Woodward-Hoffmann addition to a nickel bis(dithiolene) complex: The reaction mechanism involves reduced, dimetallic intermediates

Li Dang, Mohamed F. Shibl, Xinzheng Yang, Daniel J. Harrison, Aiman Alak, Alan J. Lough, Ulrich Fekl, Edward Brothers, Michael B. Hall

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

24 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Nickel dithiolene complexes have been proposed as electrocatalysts for alkene purification. Recent studies of the ligand-based reactions of Ni(tfd)2 (tfd = S2C2(CF3) 2) and its anion [Ni(tfd)2]- with alkenes (ethylene and 1-hexene) showed that in the absence of the anion, the reaction proceeds most rapidly to form the intraligand adduct, which decomposes by releasing a substituted dihydrodithiin. However, the presence of the anion increases the rate of formation of the stable cis-interligand adduct, and decreases the rate of dihydrodithiin formation and decomposition. In spite of both computational and experimental studies, the mechanism, especially the role of the anion, remained somewhat elusive. We are now providing a combined experimental and computational study that addresses the mechanism and explains the role of the anion. A kinetic study (global analysis) for the reaction of 1-hexene is reported, which supports the following mechanism: (1) reversible intraligand addition, (2) oxidation of the intraligand addition product prior to decomposition, and (3) interligand adduct formation catalyzed by Ni(tfd) 2 -. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed on the Ni(tfd)2/Ni(tfd)2 -/ethylene system to shed light on the selectivity of adduct formation in the absence of anion and on the mechanism in which Ni(tfd)2 - shifts the reaction from intraligand addition to interligand addition. Computational results show that in the neutral system the free energy of activation for intraligand addition is lower than that for interligand addition, in agreement with the experimental results. The computations predict that the anion enhances the rate of the cis-interligand adduct formation by forming a dimetallic complex with the neutral complex. The [(Ni(tfd)2)2]- dimetallic complex then coordinates ethylene and isomerizes to form a Ni,S-bound ethylene complex, which then rapidly isomerizes to the stable interligand adduct but not to the intraligand adduct. Thus, the anion catalyzes the formation of the interligand adduct. Significant experimental evidence for dimetallic species derived from nickel bis(dithiolene) complexes has been found. ESI-MS data indicate the presence of a [(Ni(tfd)2)2] - dimetallic complex as the acetonitrile adduct. A charge-neutral association complex of Ni(tfd)2 with the ethylene adduct of Ni(tfd)2 has been crystallographically characterized. Despite the small driving force for the reversible association, very major structural reorganization (square-planar → octahedral) occurs.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)3711-3723
Number of pages13
JournalInorganic Chemistry
Volume52
Issue number7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 2013

Fingerprint

Nickel
adducts
Anions
nickel
anions
ethylene
Alkenes
hexenes
alkenes
Association reactions
Decomposition
Electrocatalysts
decomposition
electrocatalysts
Free energy
Purification
Density functional theory
releasing
purification
Chemical activation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Inorganic Chemistry
  • Physical and Theoretical Chemistry

Cite this

Apparent anti-Woodward-Hoffmann addition to a nickel bis(dithiolene) complex : The reaction mechanism involves reduced, dimetallic intermediates. / Dang, Li; Shibl, Mohamed F.; Yang, Xinzheng; Harrison, Daniel J.; Alak, Aiman; Lough, Alan J.; Fekl, Ulrich; Brothers, Edward; Hall, Michael B.

In: Inorganic Chemistry, Vol. 52, No. 7, 01.04.2013, p. 3711-3723.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Dang, Li ; Shibl, Mohamed F. ; Yang, Xinzheng ; Harrison, Daniel J. ; Alak, Aiman ; Lough, Alan J. ; Fekl, Ulrich ; Brothers, Edward ; Hall, Michael B. / Apparent anti-Woodward-Hoffmann addition to a nickel bis(dithiolene) complex : The reaction mechanism involves reduced, dimetallic intermediates. In: Inorganic Chemistry. 2013 ; Vol. 52, No. 7. pp. 3711-3723.
@article{a8985f39e26b43df8540ae9e1f46e3c0,
title = "Apparent anti-Woodward-Hoffmann addition to a nickel bis(dithiolene) complex: The reaction mechanism involves reduced, dimetallic intermediates",
abstract = "Nickel dithiolene complexes have been proposed as electrocatalysts for alkene purification. Recent studies of the ligand-based reactions of Ni(tfd)2 (tfd = S2C2(CF3) 2) and its anion [Ni(tfd)2]- with alkenes (ethylene and 1-hexene) showed that in the absence of the anion, the reaction proceeds most rapidly to form the intraligand adduct, which decomposes by releasing a substituted dihydrodithiin. However, the presence of the anion increases the rate of formation of the stable cis-interligand adduct, and decreases the rate of dihydrodithiin formation and decomposition. In spite of both computational and experimental studies, the mechanism, especially the role of the anion, remained somewhat elusive. We are now providing a combined experimental and computational study that addresses the mechanism and explains the role of the anion. A kinetic study (global analysis) for the reaction of 1-hexene is reported, which supports the following mechanism: (1) reversible intraligand addition, (2) oxidation of the intraligand addition product prior to decomposition, and (3) interligand adduct formation catalyzed by Ni(tfd) 2 -. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed on the Ni(tfd)2/Ni(tfd)2 -/ethylene system to shed light on the selectivity of adduct formation in the absence of anion and on the mechanism in which Ni(tfd)2 - shifts the reaction from intraligand addition to interligand addition. Computational results show that in the neutral system the free energy of activation for intraligand addition is lower than that for interligand addition, in agreement with the experimental results. The computations predict that the anion enhances the rate of the cis-interligand adduct formation by forming a dimetallic complex with the neutral complex. The [(Ni(tfd)2)2]- dimetallic complex then coordinates ethylene and isomerizes to form a Ni,S-bound ethylene complex, which then rapidly isomerizes to the stable interligand adduct but not to the intraligand adduct. Thus, the anion catalyzes the formation of the interligand adduct. Significant experimental evidence for dimetallic species derived from nickel bis(dithiolene) complexes has been found. ESI-MS data indicate the presence of a [(Ni(tfd)2)2] - dimetallic complex as the acetonitrile adduct. A charge-neutral association complex of Ni(tfd)2 with the ethylene adduct of Ni(tfd)2 has been crystallographically characterized. Despite the small driving force for the reversible association, very major structural reorganization (square-planar → octahedral) occurs.",
author = "Li Dang and Shibl, {Mohamed F.} and Xinzheng Yang and Harrison, {Daniel J.} and Aiman Alak and Lough, {Alan J.} and Ulrich Fekl and Edward Brothers and Hall, {Michael B.}",
year = "2013",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1021/ic302236u",
language = "English",
volume = "52",
pages = "3711--3723",
journal = "Inorganic Chemistry",
issn = "0020-1669",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
number = "7",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Apparent anti-Woodward-Hoffmann addition to a nickel bis(dithiolene) complex

T2 - The reaction mechanism involves reduced, dimetallic intermediates

AU - Dang, Li

AU - Shibl, Mohamed F.

AU - Yang, Xinzheng

AU - Harrison, Daniel J.

AU - Alak, Aiman

AU - Lough, Alan J.

AU - Fekl, Ulrich

AU - Brothers, Edward

AU - Hall, Michael B.

PY - 2013/4/1

Y1 - 2013/4/1

N2 - Nickel dithiolene complexes have been proposed as electrocatalysts for alkene purification. Recent studies of the ligand-based reactions of Ni(tfd)2 (tfd = S2C2(CF3) 2) and its anion [Ni(tfd)2]- with alkenes (ethylene and 1-hexene) showed that in the absence of the anion, the reaction proceeds most rapidly to form the intraligand adduct, which decomposes by releasing a substituted dihydrodithiin. However, the presence of the anion increases the rate of formation of the stable cis-interligand adduct, and decreases the rate of dihydrodithiin formation and decomposition. In spite of both computational and experimental studies, the mechanism, especially the role of the anion, remained somewhat elusive. We are now providing a combined experimental and computational study that addresses the mechanism and explains the role of the anion. A kinetic study (global analysis) for the reaction of 1-hexene is reported, which supports the following mechanism: (1) reversible intraligand addition, (2) oxidation of the intraligand addition product prior to decomposition, and (3) interligand adduct formation catalyzed by Ni(tfd) 2 -. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed on the Ni(tfd)2/Ni(tfd)2 -/ethylene system to shed light on the selectivity of adduct formation in the absence of anion and on the mechanism in which Ni(tfd)2 - shifts the reaction from intraligand addition to interligand addition. Computational results show that in the neutral system the free energy of activation for intraligand addition is lower than that for interligand addition, in agreement with the experimental results. The computations predict that the anion enhances the rate of the cis-interligand adduct formation by forming a dimetallic complex with the neutral complex. The [(Ni(tfd)2)2]- dimetallic complex then coordinates ethylene and isomerizes to form a Ni,S-bound ethylene complex, which then rapidly isomerizes to the stable interligand adduct but not to the intraligand adduct. Thus, the anion catalyzes the formation of the interligand adduct. Significant experimental evidence for dimetallic species derived from nickel bis(dithiolene) complexes has been found. ESI-MS data indicate the presence of a [(Ni(tfd)2)2] - dimetallic complex as the acetonitrile adduct. A charge-neutral association complex of Ni(tfd)2 with the ethylene adduct of Ni(tfd)2 has been crystallographically characterized. Despite the small driving force for the reversible association, very major structural reorganization (square-planar → octahedral) occurs.

AB - Nickel dithiolene complexes have been proposed as electrocatalysts for alkene purification. Recent studies of the ligand-based reactions of Ni(tfd)2 (tfd = S2C2(CF3) 2) and its anion [Ni(tfd)2]- with alkenes (ethylene and 1-hexene) showed that in the absence of the anion, the reaction proceeds most rapidly to form the intraligand adduct, which decomposes by releasing a substituted dihydrodithiin. However, the presence of the anion increases the rate of formation of the stable cis-interligand adduct, and decreases the rate of dihydrodithiin formation and decomposition. In spite of both computational and experimental studies, the mechanism, especially the role of the anion, remained somewhat elusive. We are now providing a combined experimental and computational study that addresses the mechanism and explains the role of the anion. A kinetic study (global analysis) for the reaction of 1-hexene is reported, which supports the following mechanism: (1) reversible intraligand addition, (2) oxidation of the intraligand addition product prior to decomposition, and (3) interligand adduct formation catalyzed by Ni(tfd) 2 -. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed on the Ni(tfd)2/Ni(tfd)2 -/ethylene system to shed light on the selectivity of adduct formation in the absence of anion and on the mechanism in which Ni(tfd)2 - shifts the reaction from intraligand addition to interligand addition. Computational results show that in the neutral system the free energy of activation for intraligand addition is lower than that for interligand addition, in agreement with the experimental results. The computations predict that the anion enhances the rate of the cis-interligand adduct formation by forming a dimetallic complex with the neutral complex. The [(Ni(tfd)2)2]- dimetallic complex then coordinates ethylene and isomerizes to form a Ni,S-bound ethylene complex, which then rapidly isomerizes to the stable interligand adduct but not to the intraligand adduct. Thus, the anion catalyzes the formation of the interligand adduct. Significant experimental evidence for dimetallic species derived from nickel bis(dithiolene) complexes has been found. ESI-MS data indicate the presence of a [(Ni(tfd)2)2] - dimetallic complex as the acetonitrile adduct. A charge-neutral association complex of Ni(tfd)2 with the ethylene adduct of Ni(tfd)2 has been crystallographically characterized. Despite the small driving force for the reversible association, very major structural reorganization (square-planar → octahedral) occurs.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84875786527&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84875786527&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1021/ic302236u

DO - 10.1021/ic302236u

M3 - Article

C2 - 23484481

AN - SCOPUS:84875786527

VL - 52

SP - 3711

EP - 3723

JO - Inorganic Chemistry

JF - Inorganic Chemistry

SN - 0020-1669

IS - 7

ER -