After-closure idiosyncrasies of Fracture Calibration Test analysis in shale formations

Matteo Marongiu-Porcu, Albertus Retnanto

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Fracture Calibration Tests (FCT), are strategically used to estimate, amongst other important parameters, reservoir permeability and pore pressure during early appraisal stages of unconventional formations, where estimation of permeability and pore pressure by pressure transient buildup tests is impossible because no flow occurs without hydraulic fracture stimulation. This study investigates some of the idiosyncrasies that have been reported in a large number of FCTs, which make after-closure (AC) analysis ambiguous or inconsistent. We recently introduced a novel comprehensive model for FCT analysis, combining before-closure (BC) and AC behavior in a fully consistent way, facilitating the detection of abnormal BC events (i.e. multiple closure and non-linear leakoff) and improving the intrinsic weakness of standalone AC analysis methods. Extensive use of this model on a vast number of shale gas FCTs has revealed the existence of apparent AC anomalies. This paper provides a novel approach to identify and diagnose these apparent anomalies and reconcile them with unique aspects of the tested unconventional shale formations. In the AC anomaly that we firstly addressed in SPE-144028-MS, the logarithmic derivative shows only a minimal indication of formation linear flow, showing instead an abrupt transition to pseudo-radial flow. This unresolved anomaly inspired the work presented in this paper, where twenty FCT published case histories were used to study and reveal four distinct anomalies: - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits unit slope, a symptom of horizontal fracture; - Multiple closures followed by AC logarithmic derivative that exhibits a late-time "hook"; - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits abrupt transition to pseudo-radial flow with limited or no linear flow; - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits an apparent dual porosity "dip". These AC idiosyncrasies have been rationalized and integrated into our established comprehensive model for FCT analysis, allowing a realistic characterization of the geological, tectonic, and wellbore-related geometric signatures that very commonly manifest themselves in all shale formations.

Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2017
EventSPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition 2017 - San Antonio, United States
Duration: 9 Oct 201711 Oct 2017

Other

OtherSPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition 2017
CountryUnited States
CitySan Antonio
Period9/10/1711/10/17

Fingerprint

Shale
Calibration
Derivatives
Radial flow
Pore pressure
Hooks
Tectonics
Porosity
Hydraulics

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Fuel Technology
  • Energy Engineering and Power Technology

Cite this

Marongiu-Porcu, M., & Retnanto, A. (2017). After-closure idiosyncrasies of Fracture Calibration Test analysis in shale formations. Paper presented at SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition 2017, San Antonio, United States.

After-closure idiosyncrasies of Fracture Calibration Test analysis in shale formations. / Marongiu-Porcu, Matteo; Retnanto, Albertus.

2017. Paper presented at SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition 2017, San Antonio, United States.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Marongiu-Porcu, M & Retnanto, A 2017, 'After-closure idiosyncrasies of Fracture Calibration Test analysis in shale formations' Paper presented at SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition 2017, San Antonio, United States, 9/10/17 - 11/10/17, .
Marongiu-Porcu M, Retnanto A. After-closure idiosyncrasies of Fracture Calibration Test analysis in shale formations. 2017. Paper presented at SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition 2017, San Antonio, United States.
Marongiu-Porcu, Matteo ; Retnanto, Albertus. / After-closure idiosyncrasies of Fracture Calibration Test analysis in shale formations. Paper presented at SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition 2017, San Antonio, United States.
@conference{2067043f64ae48c1a27bce664c224f00,
title = "After-closure idiosyncrasies of Fracture Calibration Test analysis in shale formations",
abstract = "Fracture Calibration Tests (FCT), are strategically used to estimate, amongst other important parameters, reservoir permeability and pore pressure during early appraisal stages of unconventional formations, where estimation of permeability and pore pressure by pressure transient buildup tests is impossible because no flow occurs without hydraulic fracture stimulation. This study investigates some of the idiosyncrasies that have been reported in a large number of FCTs, which make after-closure (AC) analysis ambiguous or inconsistent. We recently introduced a novel comprehensive model for FCT analysis, combining before-closure (BC) and AC behavior in a fully consistent way, facilitating the detection of abnormal BC events (i.e. multiple closure and non-linear leakoff) and improving the intrinsic weakness of standalone AC analysis methods. Extensive use of this model on a vast number of shale gas FCTs has revealed the existence of apparent AC anomalies. This paper provides a novel approach to identify and diagnose these apparent anomalies and reconcile them with unique aspects of the tested unconventional shale formations. In the AC anomaly that we firstly addressed in SPE-144028-MS, the logarithmic derivative shows only a minimal indication of formation linear flow, showing instead an abrupt transition to pseudo-radial flow. This unresolved anomaly inspired the work presented in this paper, where twenty FCT published case histories were used to study and reveal four distinct anomalies: - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits unit slope, a symptom of horizontal fracture; - Multiple closures followed by AC logarithmic derivative that exhibits a late-time {"}hook{"}; - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits abrupt transition to pseudo-radial flow with limited or no linear flow; - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits an apparent dual porosity {"}dip{"}. These AC idiosyncrasies have been rationalized and integrated into our established comprehensive model for FCT analysis, allowing a realistic characterization of the geological, tectonic, and wellbore-related geometric signatures that very commonly manifest themselves in all shale formations.",
author = "Matteo Marongiu-Porcu and Albertus Retnanto",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
note = "SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition 2017 ; Conference date: 09-10-2017 Through 11-10-2017",

}

TY - CONF

T1 - After-closure idiosyncrasies of Fracture Calibration Test analysis in shale formations

AU - Marongiu-Porcu, Matteo

AU - Retnanto, Albertus

PY - 2017/1/1

Y1 - 2017/1/1

N2 - Fracture Calibration Tests (FCT), are strategically used to estimate, amongst other important parameters, reservoir permeability and pore pressure during early appraisal stages of unconventional formations, where estimation of permeability and pore pressure by pressure transient buildup tests is impossible because no flow occurs without hydraulic fracture stimulation. This study investigates some of the idiosyncrasies that have been reported in a large number of FCTs, which make after-closure (AC) analysis ambiguous or inconsistent. We recently introduced a novel comprehensive model for FCT analysis, combining before-closure (BC) and AC behavior in a fully consistent way, facilitating the detection of abnormal BC events (i.e. multiple closure and non-linear leakoff) and improving the intrinsic weakness of standalone AC analysis methods. Extensive use of this model on a vast number of shale gas FCTs has revealed the existence of apparent AC anomalies. This paper provides a novel approach to identify and diagnose these apparent anomalies and reconcile them with unique aspects of the tested unconventional shale formations. In the AC anomaly that we firstly addressed in SPE-144028-MS, the logarithmic derivative shows only a minimal indication of formation linear flow, showing instead an abrupt transition to pseudo-radial flow. This unresolved anomaly inspired the work presented in this paper, where twenty FCT published case histories were used to study and reveal four distinct anomalies: - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits unit slope, a symptom of horizontal fracture; - Multiple closures followed by AC logarithmic derivative that exhibits a late-time "hook"; - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits abrupt transition to pseudo-radial flow with limited or no linear flow; - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits an apparent dual porosity "dip". These AC idiosyncrasies have been rationalized and integrated into our established comprehensive model for FCT analysis, allowing a realistic characterization of the geological, tectonic, and wellbore-related geometric signatures that very commonly manifest themselves in all shale formations.

AB - Fracture Calibration Tests (FCT), are strategically used to estimate, amongst other important parameters, reservoir permeability and pore pressure during early appraisal stages of unconventional formations, where estimation of permeability and pore pressure by pressure transient buildup tests is impossible because no flow occurs without hydraulic fracture stimulation. This study investigates some of the idiosyncrasies that have been reported in a large number of FCTs, which make after-closure (AC) analysis ambiguous or inconsistent. We recently introduced a novel comprehensive model for FCT analysis, combining before-closure (BC) and AC behavior in a fully consistent way, facilitating the detection of abnormal BC events (i.e. multiple closure and non-linear leakoff) and improving the intrinsic weakness of standalone AC analysis methods. Extensive use of this model on a vast number of shale gas FCTs has revealed the existence of apparent AC anomalies. This paper provides a novel approach to identify and diagnose these apparent anomalies and reconcile them with unique aspects of the tested unconventional shale formations. In the AC anomaly that we firstly addressed in SPE-144028-MS, the logarithmic derivative shows only a minimal indication of formation linear flow, showing instead an abrupt transition to pseudo-radial flow. This unresolved anomaly inspired the work presented in this paper, where twenty FCT published case histories were used to study and reveal four distinct anomalies: - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits unit slope, a symptom of horizontal fracture; - Multiple closures followed by AC logarithmic derivative that exhibits a late-time "hook"; - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits abrupt transition to pseudo-radial flow with limited or no linear flow; - AC logarithmic derivative exhibits an apparent dual porosity "dip". These AC idiosyncrasies have been rationalized and integrated into our established comprehensive model for FCT analysis, allowing a realistic characterization of the geological, tectonic, and wellbore-related geometric signatures that very commonly manifest themselves in all shale formations.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85040461069&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85040461069&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Paper

ER -