A dynamical simulation of the debris disk around HD 141569A

D. R. Ardila, S. H. Lubow, D. A. Golimowski, J. E. Krist, M. Clampin, H. C. Ford, G. F. Hartig, G. D. Illingworth, F. Bartko, N. Benitez, J. P. Blakeslee, R. J. Bouwens, L. D. Bradley, T. J. Broadhurst, R. A. Brown, C. J. Burrows, E. S. Cheng, N. J G Cross, P. D. Feldman, M. Franx & 19 others T. Goto, C. Gronwall, B. Holden, N. Homeier, L. Infante, R. A. Kimble, M. P. Lesser, A. R. Martel, F. Menanteau, G. R. Meurer, G. K. Miley, M. Postman, M. Sirianni, W. B. Sparks, H. D. Tran, Zlatan Tsvetanov, R. L. White, W. Zheng, A. W. Zirm

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

31 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We study the dynamical origin of the structures observed in the scattered-light images of the resolved debris disk around HD 141569A. The disk has two conspicuous spiral rings and two large-scale spiral arms. We explore the roles of radiation pressure from the central star, gas drag from the gas disk, and the tidal forces from two nearby stars in creating and maintaining these structures. The disk's color, scattering function, and infrared emission suggest that submicron-sized grains dominate the dust population observed in scattered light. CO observations indicate the presence of up to 60 M of gas. The dust grains are subject to the competing effects of expulsive radiation pressure (β > 1, where β is the ratio of the radiation and gravitational forces) and retentive gas drag. We use a simple one-dimensional axisymmetric model to show that the presence of the gas helps confine the dust and that a broad ring of dust is produced if a central hole exists in the disk. This model also suggests that the disk is in a transient, excited dynamical state, as the observed dust creation rate applied over the age of the star is inconsistent with submillimeter mass measurements. We model in two dimensions the effects of a flyby encounter between the disk and a binary star in a prograde, parabolic, coplanar orbit. We track the spatial distribution of the disk's gas, planetesimals, and dust. We conclude that the surface density distribution reflects the planetesimal distribution for a wide range of parameters. Our most viable model features a disk with initial radius 400 AU, a gas mass of 50 M, and β= 4 and suggests that the system is being observed within 4000 yr of the flyby periastron. The model reproduces some features of HD 141569A's disk, such as a broad single ring and large spiral arms, but it does not reproduce the observed multiple spiral rings or disk asymmetries nor the observed clearing in the inner disk. For the latter, we consider the effect of a 5MJ planet in an eccentric orbit on the planetesimal distribution of HD 141569A.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)986-1000
Number of pages15
JournalAstrophysical Journal
Volume627
Issue number2 I
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 10 Jul 2005
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

debris
dust
planetesimal
gas
simulation
protoplanets
gases
drag
rings
radiation pressure
stars
asymmetry
planet
scattering
eccentric orbits
clearing
spatial distribution
scattering functions
binary stars
encounters

Keywords

  • Circumstellar matter
  • Hydrodynamics
  • Planetary systems: formation
  • Planetary systems: protoplanetary disks
  • Stars: individual (HD 141569)

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

Ardila, D. R., Lubow, S. H., Golimowski, D. A., Krist, J. E., Clampin, M., Ford, H. C., ... Zirm, A. W. (2005). A dynamical simulation of the debris disk around HD 141569A. Astrophysical Journal, 627(2 I), 986-1000. https://doi.org/10.1086/430395

A dynamical simulation of the debris disk around HD 141569A. / Ardila, D. R.; Lubow, S. H.; Golimowski, D. A.; Krist, J. E.; Clampin, M.; Ford, H. C.; Hartig, G. F.; Illingworth, G. D.; Bartko, F.; Benitez, N.; Blakeslee, J. P.; Bouwens, R. J.; Bradley, L. D.; Broadhurst, T. J.; Brown, R. A.; Burrows, C. J.; Cheng, E. S.; Cross, N. J G; Feldman, P. D.; Franx, M.; Goto, T.; Gronwall, C.; Holden, B.; Homeier, N.; Infante, L.; Kimble, R. A.; Lesser, M. P.; Martel, A. R.; Menanteau, F.; Meurer, G. R.; Miley, G. K.; Postman, M.; Sirianni, M.; Sparks, W. B.; Tran, H. D.; Tsvetanov, Zlatan; White, R. L.; Zheng, W.; Zirm, A. W.

In: Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 627, No. 2 I, 10.07.2005, p. 986-1000.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ardila, DR, Lubow, SH, Golimowski, DA, Krist, JE, Clampin, M, Ford, HC, Hartig, GF, Illingworth, GD, Bartko, F, Benitez, N, Blakeslee, JP, Bouwens, RJ, Bradley, LD, Broadhurst, TJ, Brown, RA, Burrows, CJ, Cheng, ES, Cross, NJG, Feldman, PD, Franx, M, Goto, T, Gronwall, C, Holden, B, Homeier, N, Infante, L, Kimble, RA, Lesser, MP, Martel, AR, Menanteau, F, Meurer, GR, Miley, GK, Postman, M, Sirianni, M, Sparks, WB, Tran, HD, Tsvetanov, Z, White, RL, Zheng, W & Zirm, AW 2005, 'A dynamical simulation of the debris disk around HD 141569A', Astrophysical Journal, vol. 627, no. 2 I, pp. 986-1000. https://doi.org/10.1086/430395
Ardila DR, Lubow SH, Golimowski DA, Krist JE, Clampin M, Ford HC et al. A dynamical simulation of the debris disk around HD 141569A. Astrophysical Journal. 2005 Jul 10;627(2 I):986-1000. https://doi.org/10.1086/430395
Ardila, D. R. ; Lubow, S. H. ; Golimowski, D. A. ; Krist, J. E. ; Clampin, M. ; Ford, H. C. ; Hartig, G. F. ; Illingworth, G. D. ; Bartko, F. ; Benitez, N. ; Blakeslee, J. P. ; Bouwens, R. J. ; Bradley, L. D. ; Broadhurst, T. J. ; Brown, R. A. ; Burrows, C. J. ; Cheng, E. S. ; Cross, N. J G ; Feldman, P. D. ; Franx, M. ; Goto, T. ; Gronwall, C. ; Holden, B. ; Homeier, N. ; Infante, L. ; Kimble, R. A. ; Lesser, M. P. ; Martel, A. R. ; Menanteau, F. ; Meurer, G. R. ; Miley, G. K. ; Postman, M. ; Sirianni, M. ; Sparks, W. B. ; Tran, H. D. ; Tsvetanov, Zlatan ; White, R. L. ; Zheng, W. ; Zirm, A. W. / A dynamical simulation of the debris disk around HD 141569A. In: Astrophysical Journal. 2005 ; Vol. 627, No. 2 I. pp. 986-1000.
@article{f734dc43aa5a418d91b025c884e7f5ed,
title = "A dynamical simulation of the debris disk around HD 141569A",
abstract = "We study the dynamical origin of the structures observed in the scattered-light images of the resolved debris disk around HD 141569A. The disk has two conspicuous spiral rings and two large-scale spiral arms. We explore the roles of radiation pressure from the central star, gas drag from the gas disk, and the tidal forces from two nearby stars in creating and maintaining these structures. The disk's color, scattering function, and infrared emission suggest that submicron-sized grains dominate the dust population observed in scattered light. CO observations indicate the presence of up to 60 M⊕ of gas. The dust grains are subject to the competing effects of expulsive radiation pressure (β > 1, where β is the ratio of the radiation and gravitational forces) and retentive gas drag. We use a simple one-dimensional axisymmetric model to show that the presence of the gas helps confine the dust and that a broad ring of dust is produced if a central hole exists in the disk. This model also suggests that the disk is in a transient, excited dynamical state, as the observed dust creation rate applied over the age of the star is inconsistent with submillimeter mass measurements. We model in two dimensions the effects of a flyby encounter between the disk and a binary star in a prograde, parabolic, coplanar orbit. We track the spatial distribution of the disk's gas, planetesimals, and dust. We conclude that the surface density distribution reflects the planetesimal distribution for a wide range of parameters. Our most viable model features a disk with initial radius 400 AU, a gas mass of 50 M⊕, and β= 4 and suggests that the system is being observed within 4000 yr of the flyby periastron. The model reproduces some features of HD 141569A's disk, such as a broad single ring and large spiral arms, but it does not reproduce the observed multiple spiral rings or disk asymmetries nor the observed clearing in the inner disk. For the latter, we consider the effect of a 5MJ planet in an eccentric orbit on the planetesimal distribution of HD 141569A.",
keywords = "Circumstellar matter, Hydrodynamics, Planetary systems: formation, Planetary systems: protoplanetary disks, Stars: individual (HD 141569)",
author = "Ardila, {D. R.} and Lubow, {S. H.} and Golimowski, {D. A.} and Krist, {J. E.} and M. Clampin and Ford, {H. C.} and Hartig, {G. F.} and Illingworth, {G. D.} and F. Bartko and N. Benitez and Blakeslee, {J. P.} and Bouwens, {R. J.} and Bradley, {L. D.} and Broadhurst, {T. J.} and Brown, {R. A.} and Burrows, {C. J.} and Cheng, {E. S.} and Cross, {N. J G} and Feldman, {P. D.} and M. Franx and T. Goto and C. Gronwall and B. Holden and N. Homeier and L. Infante and Kimble, {R. A.} and Lesser, {M. P.} and Martel, {A. R.} and F. Menanteau and Meurer, {G. R.} and Miley, {G. K.} and M. Postman and M. Sirianni and Sparks, {W. B.} and Tran, {H. D.} and Zlatan Tsvetanov and White, {R. L.} and W. Zheng and Zirm, {A. W.}",
year = "2005",
month = "7",
day = "10",
doi = "10.1086/430395",
language = "English",
volume = "627",
pages = "986--1000",
journal = "Astrophysical Journal",
issn = "0004-637X",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "2 I",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A dynamical simulation of the debris disk around HD 141569A

AU - Ardila, D. R.

AU - Lubow, S. H.

AU - Golimowski, D. A.

AU - Krist, J. E.

AU - Clampin, M.

AU - Ford, H. C.

AU - Hartig, G. F.

AU - Illingworth, G. D.

AU - Bartko, F.

AU - Benitez, N.

AU - Blakeslee, J. P.

AU - Bouwens, R. J.

AU - Bradley, L. D.

AU - Broadhurst, T. J.

AU - Brown, R. A.

AU - Burrows, C. J.

AU - Cheng, E. S.

AU - Cross, N. J G

AU - Feldman, P. D.

AU - Franx, M.

AU - Goto, T.

AU - Gronwall, C.

AU - Holden, B.

AU - Homeier, N.

AU - Infante, L.

AU - Kimble, R. A.

AU - Lesser, M. P.

AU - Martel, A. R.

AU - Menanteau, F.

AU - Meurer, G. R.

AU - Miley, G. K.

AU - Postman, M.

AU - Sirianni, M.

AU - Sparks, W. B.

AU - Tran, H. D.

AU - Tsvetanov, Zlatan

AU - White, R. L.

AU - Zheng, W.

AU - Zirm, A. W.

PY - 2005/7/10

Y1 - 2005/7/10

N2 - We study the dynamical origin of the structures observed in the scattered-light images of the resolved debris disk around HD 141569A. The disk has two conspicuous spiral rings and two large-scale spiral arms. We explore the roles of radiation pressure from the central star, gas drag from the gas disk, and the tidal forces from two nearby stars in creating and maintaining these structures. The disk's color, scattering function, and infrared emission suggest that submicron-sized grains dominate the dust population observed in scattered light. CO observations indicate the presence of up to 60 M⊕ of gas. The dust grains are subject to the competing effects of expulsive radiation pressure (β > 1, where β is the ratio of the radiation and gravitational forces) and retentive gas drag. We use a simple one-dimensional axisymmetric model to show that the presence of the gas helps confine the dust and that a broad ring of dust is produced if a central hole exists in the disk. This model also suggests that the disk is in a transient, excited dynamical state, as the observed dust creation rate applied over the age of the star is inconsistent with submillimeter mass measurements. We model in two dimensions the effects of a flyby encounter between the disk and a binary star in a prograde, parabolic, coplanar orbit. We track the spatial distribution of the disk's gas, planetesimals, and dust. We conclude that the surface density distribution reflects the planetesimal distribution for a wide range of parameters. Our most viable model features a disk with initial radius 400 AU, a gas mass of 50 M⊕, and β= 4 and suggests that the system is being observed within 4000 yr of the flyby periastron. The model reproduces some features of HD 141569A's disk, such as a broad single ring and large spiral arms, but it does not reproduce the observed multiple spiral rings or disk asymmetries nor the observed clearing in the inner disk. For the latter, we consider the effect of a 5MJ planet in an eccentric orbit on the planetesimal distribution of HD 141569A.

AB - We study the dynamical origin of the structures observed in the scattered-light images of the resolved debris disk around HD 141569A. The disk has two conspicuous spiral rings and two large-scale spiral arms. We explore the roles of radiation pressure from the central star, gas drag from the gas disk, and the tidal forces from two nearby stars in creating and maintaining these structures. The disk's color, scattering function, and infrared emission suggest that submicron-sized grains dominate the dust population observed in scattered light. CO observations indicate the presence of up to 60 M⊕ of gas. The dust grains are subject to the competing effects of expulsive radiation pressure (β > 1, where β is the ratio of the radiation and gravitational forces) and retentive gas drag. We use a simple one-dimensional axisymmetric model to show that the presence of the gas helps confine the dust and that a broad ring of dust is produced if a central hole exists in the disk. This model also suggests that the disk is in a transient, excited dynamical state, as the observed dust creation rate applied over the age of the star is inconsistent with submillimeter mass measurements. We model in two dimensions the effects of a flyby encounter between the disk and a binary star in a prograde, parabolic, coplanar orbit. We track the spatial distribution of the disk's gas, planetesimals, and dust. We conclude that the surface density distribution reflects the planetesimal distribution for a wide range of parameters. Our most viable model features a disk with initial radius 400 AU, a gas mass of 50 M⊕, and β= 4 and suggests that the system is being observed within 4000 yr of the flyby periastron. The model reproduces some features of HD 141569A's disk, such as a broad single ring and large spiral arms, but it does not reproduce the observed multiple spiral rings or disk asymmetries nor the observed clearing in the inner disk. For the latter, we consider the effect of a 5MJ planet in an eccentric orbit on the planetesimal distribution of HD 141569A.

KW - Circumstellar matter

KW - Hydrodynamics

KW - Planetary systems: formation

KW - Planetary systems: protoplanetary disks

KW - Stars: individual (HD 141569)

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=25444473789&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=25444473789&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1086/430395

DO - 10.1086/430395

M3 - Article

VL - 627

SP - 986

EP - 1000

JO - Astrophysical Journal

JF - Astrophysical Journal

SN - 0004-637X

IS - 2 I

ER -